Newspaper logo  
   Proposed Chemical Safety Bill Considered Essential First Step in Preventing Chemical Disasters


Proposed Chemical Safety Bill Considered Essential First Step in Preventing Chemical Disasters

by Rick Hind, Legislative Director,
Greenpeace Toxics Campaign
The U.S. Army's surgeon general estimates that 2.4 million people could be killed or injured in a terrorist attack--or, more likely, an accident--at just one of 123 major U.S. toxic chemical plants. One of these is Condea Vista in Baltimore. How secure are such plants? Not very: a Pittsburgh reporter recently anonymously walked into more than 60 US chemical plants without challenge.
July 25, 2002--The magnitude of a terrorist attack on U.S. chemical facilities could easily exceed the loss of life suffered on September 11th of last year. Recent events underscore the immediacy of this threat, including a series of nation-wide security alerts by the FBI and a 72-hour moratorium by the railroad industry on carrying chemicals such as chlorine in October, 2001.

Even President Bush was at risk. On September 11, when Air Force One landed in Louisiana, the President joined more than a million Louisiana residents who live every day in a region that is blanketed by chemical "kill zones." These kill zones surround more than 100 petro-chemical facilities located along the Mississippi River between Baton Rouge and New Orleans. A 1999 federal government study of the U.S. chemical industry found security against terrorists to be "fair to poor."

According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), more than 120 chemical facilities in the U.S. each threaten a million or more nearby residents. The Surgeon General of the U.S. Army identified chemical plants as second only to bio-terrorism in terrorist threats in the US.

Similarly, a 2002 Brookings Institute report ranked chemical facilities third in the number of fatalities that could occur from a terrorist attack. And the 2001 Argonne National Laboratory study reported, "The failure to identify and evaluate opportunities to reduce the risks from these types of relatively rare accidents could ultimately lead to thousands of fatalities, injuries, and evacuations."

Thankfully, there has never been a terrorist attack on a U.S. chemical facility. But there have been more than 3,000 accidents involving more than 10,000 pounds of hazardous materials since 1987, with smaller incidents occurring daily.

Senator Jon Corzine (D-NJ) has introduced a bill (S. 1602) that not only requires beefed up security by the chemical industry but puts prevention first, to ultimately eliminate or reduce the possibility of a chemical release by encouraging inherently safer technologies. The EPA is also drafting similar legislation and new regulations.

In 2002, the Dutch government announced that they will set aside $395 million to help relocate polluting or dangerous facilities away from cities. The French are considering similar steps.

In the U.S., 15,000 facilities across the U.S. are required to report their worst-case accident scenarios to the EPA. These reports contain estimates on the distance that a super toxic chemical cloud could extend over neighboring populations. Pressure has recently been put on the EPA to deny public access to this basic information.

Denying access to these reports will only accomplish one thing: it will leave the public without vital information needed to protect themselves in the event of an attack or an accident. Hiding basic hazard information from the public undermines the credibility of government and industry and will lead to dedicated terrorists being the only non-governmental people outside industry to have this information.

Virtually all of the EPA data supplied by industry reports is publicly available elsewhere. To produce the posted Greenpeace maps, all that was used from the EPA reports were the names of toxic chemical(s) used or stored at facilities and the distance they estimate a poison gas cloud would travel in an accident. The reports also contain estimates of the number of people living and working in the danger zone, based on U.S. Census data. None of this information would be difficult for determined terrorists to acquire from other publicly available sources such as industry publications, libraries, U.S. Census Bureau and publicly available maps.

Unfortunately, after using terrorism as an argument to hide potential chemical disasters, the U.S. chemical industry has done little to eliminate the threats posed by chemical facilities. In March 2001, Greenpeace exposed a significant example of this failure by publishing photographic evidence from inside a Dow Chemical plant in Plaquemine, Louisiana. The photos show the internal control panels and operating instructions of an unguarded pump house that releases 550 million gallons of wastewater into the Mississippi River every day.

While investigating Dow's Clean Water Act violations, Greenpeace activists entered this facility undetected. There were no guards at the perimeter, no security cameras and no burglar alarms. In fact, the door to the building was unlocked. All of these are rudimentary security measures that the EPA recommended in a February 2000 security alert. The EPA also recommended "design" changes in plants that few facilities have implemented.

Greenpeace recommends a set of short and long-term steps to truly eliminate these unnecessary and preventable disasters. In the short-term these include the immediate: adoption of S. 1602 by Congress, implementation of a program to end the transport of large quantities of poisonous chemicals, reduction in storage of similar substances to quantities that cannot threaten area populations, and decentralized production of these substances to eliminate the need for large container transport and storage.

In Washington D.C., the local sewage treatment plant has already accelerated by one year an end to their use of highly toxic chlorine gas due to its potential use by terrorists. The plant is only four miles from the U.S. Capitol. According to the National Transportation Safety Board and the Coast Guard, a large leak of chlorine gas can travel two miles in only 10 minutes and remain acutely toxic to a distance of about 20 miles.

In the long term, virtually all of the ultra-hazardous chemicals used in the U.S. have safer substitutes and conversion to them should begin today. The U.S. needs many things to function, like the besieged airline industry and the postal system. What it does not need is to continue producing obsolete and ultra-hazardous chemicals that pose enormous risks to the public--with or without the threat of terrorist attack.

More information about the potential dangers of chemical accidents can be found here. Copies of Greenpeace's latest "kill zone map," which were provided to the EPA's office of Homeland Security on April 2, 2002, can be accessed from the website.

See Greenpeace's companion story, What Have We Learned From the Baltimore Train Tunnel Disaster?, also in this issue.

Copyright © 2003 The Baltimore Chronicle and The Sentinel. All rights reserved. We invite your comments, criticisms and suggestions.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle and Sentinel content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on August 7, 2002.
· ELECTION: How Do US Representatives from MD Stack Up on Civil Liberties?
· Forgotten Insurrection at Camden Yards Shows How We Are Disconnected from Our History
· AIDS 2002: Public Forum on HIV Treatment Set for Tuesday, August 20
· One Year Later: What Have We Learned From the Baltimore Train Tunnel Disaster?
· How To Come Back from the Brink of Foreclosure
· Super Kids Camps Combine Literacy with Outings
· Sports: Football, Fun and Family
·Book Review: "The Outfit: The Role of Chicago's Underworld in the Shaping Of Modern America"
·Book Review:"Russian Experiences: Life in the Former USSR and Post-Soviet Russia"
·Operation TIPS Hotline Transcript, as Overheard on the line at the Jones Household
·EDITORIAL: The Posse Comitatus Issue: Military's Role in Domestic Law Enforcement Must Be Strictly Limited
·King George Creating East-Bloc Amerika
·Die Pop Up, Die!
·SOAPBOX: Maybe We Need Protection from Protection
·Open Letter to America from a Canadian
·Open Letter to the owners and players of major league baseball...
·An open letter to the members of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee...
·Condoleeza: Brown Rice As Bleached As White
·Why We Should Add 'None of the Above' to the Ballot
·Leo Tolstoy's Last Message to Mankind
·The Washington Post and the Road to War Against Iraq
·The Washington Post and the Road to Dictatorship
· Pervez Musharraf: What the West Doesn't Know--or Doesn't Want to Know
· History of Chávez: Why He Upsets DC
· (8/28) How's Chávez Doing?
· War on Terrorism or Police State?
· What Is the Posse Comitatus Act?
· Rep. Cardin Introduces Medicare Prescription Drug Bill
· Proposed Chemical Safety Bill Considered Essential First Step in Preventing Chemical Disasters
· Websites We Like!
· Outstanding Analysis & Perspective

Public Service Ads: