Newspaper logo  
 
 
Print view: Can This Environmentally Challenged World Be Saved? 'The Upcycle' Says It Can
BOOK REVIEW:

Can This Environmentally Challenged World Be Saved? The Upcycle Says It Can

Review by Alice Cherbonnier
THE UPCYCLE: Beyond Sustainability—Designing for Abundance
by William McDonough and Michael Braungart
©2013 North Point Press, a division of Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, NY. Paperback; $24
"Human beings don't have a pollution problem; they have a design problem," the authors stress.

Back in 2002, U.S. architect William McDonough and German scientist Michael Braungart published Cradle to Cradle, a book that laid out a compelling case for creating a sustainable world by reinventing how products are made and disposed of. Incremental change, they said persuasively, isn't going to cut it if we are to solve the many environmental problems the world is facing.

Now, 11 years later, the duo has published a follow-up book, The Upcycle, which details important successes of Cradle to Cradle implementation and steps up the game even more: now the authors are exhorting us not only to rethink design and manufacturing processes from beginning to end, in order to eliminate waste and have a “net zero” impact; they're saying that just getting to "net zero" or "neutral" isn't enough. They show how it's possible to plan cradle-to-cradle processes that end up with environmental benefits at the end of the cycle. The goal isn't to be "less bad" and eliminate adverse consequences, it’s to be "more good.”

The authors claim that the upcycle approach will reduce government regulations because, with ill effects eliminated, there’ll be less to regulate.

The authors are well-connected heavy hitters in environmental thinking. McDonough consulted on the celebrated "Make It Right" program, which incorporated cradle-to-cradle principles to the new homes the program, with Brad Pitt's involvement, has been building in post-Katrina New Orleans' hard-hit Lower Ninth Ward. Braungart wrote "The Hannover Principles," international "green design" guidelines promulgated for the 2000 World's Fair in that German city. And this book's foreward is by none other than President Bill Clinton.

McDonough and Braungart have been able to convince their client corporations and institutions, ranging from NASA to Walmart, that implementing cradle-to-cradle principles is not only responsible citizenship, it's profitable. They also claim that the upcycle approach will reduce government regulations because, with ill effects eliminated, there will be less to regulate.

With the exception of water, sunshine and "the occasional meteor," everything the Earth is ever going to have exists here right now and must be husbanded for future generations.

Among their recommendations: Capture and recycle essentials like carbon and phosphate. Add nothing toxic to materials from the beginning of a process, rather than remove them at the end. Make sure, if a problem is eliminated, that another problem isn’t created. Design in concert with nature, using the sun for light and power, the earth for water and cooling, the air for circulation. Harness the energy from decomposing methane and carbon dioxide. Preserve topsoil. Build vertical greenhouses. Recycle sewage and urine—both can be done safely. View the Earth as a battery, and keep it charged. Understand that with the exception of water, sunshine and "the occasional meteor," everything the Earth is ever going to have exists here right now and must be husbanded for future generations.

"Human beings don't have a pollution problem; they have a design problem," the authors stress. Too often, they say, design is considered only for the "first use" of a product, without thought of the product's downstream impact. Instead, they call for beneficially designing for every stage of a product's existence, including disassembly and repurposing.

The authors’ vision, they acknowledge, can only work if far more individuals and entities become involved in the cradle-to-cradle and upcycle efforts. They’re pushing to create a “butterfly effect,” where successful efforts inspire others, resulting in a magnification of benefits. They’re aware that they may seem to be naive and over-optimistic about human nature, but show, through examples already occurring all over the world, that cradle-to-cradle manufacturing and upcycling do work.

McDonough and Brungart have performed a public service by detailing their work and outlining the many environmental considerations the public needs to understand. Unfortunately, The Upcycle sometimes reads like a self-promotional tract, with too much about the authors’ work and less about the work of others.

Though The Upcycle, as a book, has been manufactured to the best-available standards of beneficient environmental sustainability, its visual design is nowhere near as attractive as the supple and sophisticated “paper”-back Cradle to Cradle. The typography of The Upcycle is uninspired, with insufficient differentiation between subheads and text, awkward and unattractive margins and indentations, and peculiar chapter dividers. The graphics are amateurish and superfluous. Several light gray inserts are awkwardly interspersed in the text; though these should signal information of special importance, instead they are crammed with tiny text that adds little to the book’s message.

Worst of all, for a book that concerns science and product engineering, there is no index.

Considering the importance of the authors' message, these design shortcomings detract too much. This book could use an “upcycle” of its own, and the sooner the better. The world is waiting.


Alice Cherbonnier, managing editor of the Baltimore Chronicle, is working on a book about the connection between Plessy v. Ferguson and New Orleans social activists from 1850 through 1895.



Copyright © 2013 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own.

This story was published on June 30, 2013.

 
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education
Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

11.18 How Extreme Weather Is Shrinking the Planet

11.18 Air pollution levels ‘forcing families to move out of cities’ [like from desertification, lack of drinkable water and rising oceans, there will also be pollution-caused immigration until humans fix things]

11.17 Policies of China, Russia and Canada threaten 5C climate change, study finds [Climate catastrophe is increasingly likely without worldwide organization, funding and commitment to winning THE WAR AGAINST GLOBAL WARMING.]

11.16 Scotland was first Industrialized Country to Run wholly on Wind in October

11.16 How pesticide bans can prevent tens of thousands of suicides a year [how many thousands more die early from eating pesticide-laced food?]

11.15 The Earth is in a death spiral. It will take radical action to save us [fossil fuel burning, un-recyclable plastic production/use and methane gas release must cease ASAP.]

11.15  The long read:  The plastic backlash: what's behind our sudden rage – and will it make a difference? [the world wants to throw-up...]

11.15 Claws out: crab fishermen sue 30 oil firms over climate change [workers are waking-up...]

11.15 Trump administration to cut air pollution from heavy-duty trucks

11.14 Backed by Ocasio-Cortez, Youth Climate Activists Arrested in Pelosi's Office Demanding Democrats Embrace 'Green New Deal'

11.13 What would a smog-free city look like?

11.13 Global report highlights Australia’s renewables potential amid mixed signals for coal

11.13 Interior department whistleblower: Ryan Zinke hollowed out the agency

11.12  This Land is Your Land:  The Zinke effect: how the US interior department became a tool of industry [behaving ignorantly again...]

11.12 Planned Parenthood's new president warns of 'state of emergency' for women's health

News Media Matters

11.19 The Biggest Threat to Free Speech No One Is Talking About

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

11.19 Last Week Tonight with John Oliver 11/18/2018 (HBO) [29:26 video]

11.19 Michael Bloomberg: Why I’m Giving $1.8 Billion for College Financial Aid

11.19 Trump’s Diminishing Power and Rising Rage

11.19 Trump Says He Was 'Fully Briefed' and Also 'Not Briefed Yet' But Either Way Saudi Crown Prince 'Absolutely' Not Involved Because Trump Knows 'Everything That Went On' Without Listening to Tape of Khashoggi Murder

11.19 'We Need New Leaders, Period': Progressive Newcomers Urge Democrats to Embrace Bold Agenda or Face Primary Challenges [Current Democrat leaders are highly compromised by corporate donations]

11.19 SNL explains Jeff Bezos and Amazon’s HQ2 strategy: trolling President Trump [2:55 SNL video]

11.18 Trump says Pelosi deserves speakership, offers Republican votes [An affirmation of Pelosi's unsuitability]

11.18 Khanna to Pelosi: Don't Just Create Green New Deal Select Committee, Make Ocasio-Cortez Its Chair [Will Pelosi earnestly change, or end her career in disgrace?]

11.18 Chuck Schumer, Feckless Hack [Neoliberal Democrats must go!]

11.18 What the State of the VA Tells Us About Trump’s War on Welfare [Privatizing often results in outright fraud and higher costs by private prisons, privatized health insurance and health care, privatized public schools and online "colleges" like Trump University]

11.17 What the State of the VA Tells Us About Trump’s War on Welfare

11.17 As Energy for Medicare for All Explodes, Steny Hoyer's Plan Includes Waiting for Trump to Help Make Obamacare Better [Another who is unfit to be Democrat leader]

11.17 'A Staggeringly Bad Idea': Outrage as Pelosi Pushes Tax Rule That Would 'Kneecap the Progressive Agenda' [Unfit to be Democrat leader]

11.17 Trump Is Starting to Panic

Justice Matters
High Crimes?

11.14 The Guardian view on Yemen’s misery: the west is complicit [WAR CRIMES]

Economics, Crony Capitalism

11.19 Bankrupt Sears wants to give executives $19 million in bonuses [blatantly immoral and sick to richly reward those who led the company into the bankruptcy]

11.18 Big Pharma Bankrolled Pro-Trump Group As Trump Pushed Pharma Tax Cut [Corruption Central!]

11.16 Amazon’s HQ2 Will Get a Tax Break Designed to Help the Poor [a Republican program that directly helps participating wealthy companies—but only helps workers if and when 'trickle-down' occurs.]

11.16 Trump doesn’t want to punish Saudi Arabia over Khashoggi. His new sanctions prove it. [George W. Bush made a similar immoral decision for the same oily reasons after 9-11, protecting Saudi defense contracts while facilitating the slaughter of poorer Arab "terrorists" in the region.]

International & Futurism

11.18 New Evidence Emerges of Steve Bannon and Cambridge Analytica’s Role in Brexit

11.18 France demands UK climate pledge in return for Brexit trade deal [Excellent!]

11.17 Saudi crown prince's 'fit' delays UN resolution on war in Yemen

11.17 Thousands gather to block London bridges in climate rebellion [We're losing WWIII because the enemy is invisible while we're like frogs slowly cooking. We aren't informed enough to be alarmed, but must get organized and motivated to fight back. We need a War Plan to ruthlessly pursue the fight of our lives!]

11.17 CIA finds Saudi crown prince ordered Jamal Khashoggi killing – report

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web
 

Public Service Ads: